Myths About Electric Vehicle Limitations in Long-Haul Trips Debunked

The evolution of electric vehicles (EVs) has sparked a significant debate, especially regarding their capabilities for long-haul transportation. Are electric trucks ready to take on heavy-duty, long-distance transport? This question takes center stage in discussions around the future of sustainable freight mobility, particularly at the HVTT18: Trucking toward S2MART global summit. With insights from leading experts, we delve into the current state of electric truck technology, performance objectives, and the challenges ahead.

At the HVTT18 summit, Eddy Zuppel, program leader for clean and energy-efficient transportation at the National Research Council of Canada (NRC), presented findings from a comprehensive 2023 report for Transport Canada’s Zero-Emission Transportation and Trucking Program. The report covers essential aspects of battery technology, highlighting the intricacies involved in applying electric solutions to heavy-duty trucking.

Current state of battery technology: What are the challenges?

The transportation sector is a major contributor to global greenhouse gas emissions, making its decarbonization a critical objective for combating climate change. However, the transition to electric solutions presents immense challenges, particularly when it comes to the energy demands of heavy-duty vehicles.

Many technologies are under consideration for reducing emissions in this sector, including hydrogen fuel cells and alternative fuels. However, batteries remain a cornerstone technology for electric trucks, serving as the equivalent of a fuel tank in traditional diesel vehicles.

Heavy-duty trucks require significantly larger batteries—often exceeding 1,000 kWh—compared to the 60 to 75 kWh batteries found in passenger vehicles. This stark difference introduces several technical hurdles, including:

• Energy management complexities
• Durability of components
• Integration of systems

The two primary families of batteries dominating the market today are high-density chemistries, such as nickel-manganese-cobalt (NMC) and nickel-cobalt-aluminum (NCA), alongside lithium iron phosphate (LFP) batteries. Each has its strengths and weaknesses:

• NMC and NCA batteries: High energy density but costly due to cobalt content, which has an unstable supply chain. Their durability is also limited, especially at high nickel concentrations.
• LFP batteries: More affordable and safer with a lifespan exceeding 2,000 cycles, but lower energy density limits their applicability to shorter trips.

Performance objectives: Where are we heading?

The industry is setting ambitious targets for enhancing battery performance for long-distance applications. Currently, NMC batteries provide an energy density of approximately 150 Wh/kg. The ultimate goal is to achieve a range of 250 to 300 Wh/kg, which would address both weight and range limitations.

In terms of lifespan, Zuppel emphasized that the current cycle count for NMC batteries ranges between 1,000 and 2,000. For long-haul transport, a significantly higher durability is essential to justify the investment.

Another critical factor is the cost of battery packs. Presently, the expense is around $135 per kWh, but the aim is to reduce this to below $100 within the next three to four years. Achieving these price targets could potentially make electric trucks more competitive in the logistics market.

Understanding payload penalties and performance in cold climates

Another obstacle that electric trucks must overcome is the issue of payload penalties attributed to the weight of the batteries. For example, when considering a range of 500 km, the battery weight can lead to a payload reduction of approximately 10%. This penalty escalates for longer distances.

Cold climates also pose significant challenges, especially in regions like Canada. At temperatures below -8°C, electric vehicles can experience a range loss of up to 8%. This loss can escalate to 40-50% at temperatures around -25°C to -30°C, affecting not only the driving range but also the energy needed to heat the cabin and maintain optimal battery temperatures (ideally between 15 and 20°C).

To tackle these issues, the industry must adopt advanced thermal management strategies and explore new materials for better battery performance in extreme conditions. Such innovations could allow for the utilization of battery chemistries that are more resilient to temperature fluctuations.

Debunking myths surrounding electric trucks

Zuppel also aimed to dismantle several common misconceptions about electric trucks that can hinder their adoption:

Myth: Batteries are too heavy. While it's true that batteries add weight, it's important to note that most cargo limitations are based on volume rather than weight. In fact, some regions in the U.S. and Europe permit electric trucks to exceed standard weight limits to facilitate the transition to cleaner technologies.

Myth: Long-distance travel is the norm. Contrary to popular belief, over 90% of heavy-duty truck journeys in the U.S. and more than 97% in the European Union fall within 800 km, a distance that modern battery technology can already accommodate. Furthermore, the rise of e-commerce has contributed to a 40% reduction in average transport distances over the past two decades.

In the short term, manufacturers are focused on reducing battery costs by adjusting the composition of cathodes to favor higher proportions of nickel and manganese. They are also enhancing the anode side by incorporating materials like silicone to boost energy density.

In the long run, increasing the concentration of metallic lithium in the anode could lead to higher energy densities. However, this shift would necessitate the use of solid electrolytes for stability, given the volatility of lithium.

Emerging technologies hold promise as well. Lithium-sulphur and sodium-ion batteries utilize more abundant and less costly materials, but they still need advancements in energy density and lifespan to become viable alternatives.

For further insights on debunking myths around electric vehicles, check out this informative video:

As electric trucks continue to evolve, addressing these challenges and misconceptions will be crucial for their widespread adoption and successful integration into the logistics industry. The path towards decarbonization in transportation will require innovation, investment, and a commitment to overcoming the technical hurdles that lie ahead.

ACT Research examines potential air pockets in freight market

Smith System Brand Identity Update Focuses on Safety and Innovation

August 2025 Truck Orders Decrease Compared to Last Year

MTO launches new X-ray inspection technology

If you want to know other articles similar to Myths About Electric Vehicle Limitations in Long-Haul Trips Debunked you can visit the category BLOG.